The Junto Club

A Reference Authority for United States Coins

1914 Proof Buffalo Nickel

Buffalo Nickel · 1913-1938

Schedule of Prices

Asking prices by certified grade on active eBay listings — what sellers are asking, not sale prices and not a valuation.
GradeAskSample
PF66$4,625 asking1
PF66 CAC$3,250 · $3,675 asking2
PF66 CAC TNR$3,675 asking1
PF67$4,750 asking1
PF67 CAC$6,350 · $7,750 asking2
PF67+ CAC$7,750 asking1
PF68$15,300 · $17,900 asking2

Grades without listing data aren't shown.

Ask is what sellers were asking on active eBay listings of certified coins, fixed-price only — not what a coin sold for, and not our valuation. With enough listings at a grade, it's the middle 50% of their asking prices; with only a few, each asking price is shown. A single listing is shown only when its seller has an established eBay account with strong feedback. Sample is the number of listings behind each figure. Grades shown without a designation are plain examples.

Links to eBay may earn us a commission. They never affect the prices shown.

Listings observed 2026-09-20 – 2026-10-26.

See Also

Die Varieties

No die varieties recorded yet for this date.

Specifications
  • Series Buffalo Nickel (1913-1938)
  • Denomination 5¢
  • Designer James Earle Fraser
  • Composition 75% copper, 25% nickel
  • Weight 5 g
  • Diameter 21.2 mm
  • Edge Plain
  • Mintage 1,275
  • Mint mark None (Philadelphia)

History

Proof striking. Proofs were struck for collectors and sold separately from circulating coinage; this is a distinct coin from the 1914 Buffalo Nickel.

The Junto Brief

Notes on coins, values, and the hunt — delivered on occasion. No noise.

← All coins